EM-114 · Companion to the capture scope · 27 Aug 2026
Every brand below was loaded in a real browser on 27 August 2026, desktop and mobile, and watched for 27 seconds. Where a pop-up fired we recorded when it fired, what it offered, what it asked for, what the decline button said, and we screenshotted it. Where a second step existed we clicked through and screenshotted that too.
22 of 54 fired an overlay pop-up. Another 22 showed no pop-up but run an embedded signup unit, which we captured instead, so 44 brands here have a documented capture surface and a screenshot. 3 ask for a phone number anywhere on site. Every image on this page is our own capture, not a press asset.
Companion to the capture scope and ranked initiative list:
bfs-capture-scope.vercel.app
⚠ Captured from a Madrid IP. Several brands name Spain in their pop-up, so US-only pop-ups will not
have fired. Section 11 is the manual re-check worklist with every link.
One row per brand. “Fires” is seconds from page load to the pop-up appearing on desktop. Blank means nothing appeared inside 27 seconds for a browser with no history.
| Brand | Site | Category | Surface | Fires | Step 1 asks | Step 2 asks | Offer on screen | Phone | Decline copy | Pop-up vendor stack | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1st Phorm | 1stphorm.com | sports | — | — | — | — | · | · | — | Klaviyo, Digioh | |
| AG1 | drinkag1.com | mass | — | — | — | — | ✓ | · | — | Klaviyo | |
| Alani Nu | alaninutrition.com | mass | 2.5s | — | 15% off | ✓ | · | — | Klaviyo | ||
| Ancestral Supplements | ancestralsupplements.com | ancestral | 1.0s | no field, buttons only | mystery discount | ✓ | · | — | Klaviyo, Attrac | ||
| Ancient Nutrition | ancientnutrition.com | ancestral | — | — | — | $10 off | ✓ | · | — | Attentive, Justuno, Octane AI | |
| ARMRA | tryarmra.com | colostrum | 1.0s | no field, buttons only | 30% off, 5% off | ✓ | · | — | Klaviyo, OptiMonk, WisePops, Wunderkind, Emotive | ||
| Arrae | arrae.com | wellness | — | — | — | — | · | · | — | Klaviyo | |
| Bare Performance Nutrition | bpnsupps.com | sports | — | — | — | — | ✓ | · | — | Klaviyo, Attentive, OptiMonk, WisePops, Wunderkind, Octane AI, Emotive | |
| BiOptimizers | bioptimizers.com | longevity | 10.5s | same screen | — | ✓ | · | — | — | ||
| Bloom Nutrition | bloomnu.com | mass | 2.0s | no field, buttons only | mystery discount | ✓ | · | I'm not sure! | Klaviyo, Attentive, Attrac | ||
| Bucked Up | buckedup.com | sports | — | — | — | — | ✓ | ✓ | — | Klaviyo | |
| Bulletproof | bulletproof.com | mass | — | — | — | — | ✓ | · | — | Klaviyo | |
| Create Wellness | createwellness.com | sports | — | — | — | — | · | · | — | — | |
| Cymbiotika | cymbiotika.com | longevity | — | — | — | — | · | · | — | Klaviyo, Attentive, Justuno, Privy | |
| Double Wood | doublewoodsupplements.com | value | 9.0s | no field, buttons only | — | 25% off | · | · | No thanks | Klaviyo, Alia | |
| Everyday Dose | everydaydose.com | wellness | 13.0s | no field, buttons only | same screen | 70% off, free gift | · | · | No, thanks | Klaviyo, Alia | |
| Four Sigmatic | foursigmatic.com | mass | — | — | — | — | · | · | — | Klaviyo, Octane AI, Attrac | |
| Function Health | functionhealth.com | testing | — | — | — | — | ✓ | · | — | — | |
| Garden of Life | gardenoflife.com | mass | — | — | — | — | · | · | — | — | |
| Ghost Lifestyle | ghostlifestyle.com | sports | — | — | — | — | ✓ | ✓ | — | Klaviyo, Postscript, Alia | |
| Goli | goli.com | mass | 5.5s | same screen | 15% off | ✓ | · | — | Klaviyo, Attrac | ||
| Gorilla Mind | gorillamind.com | sports | — | — | — | — | · | · | — | — | |
| Heart & Soil | heartandsoil.co | ancestral | — | — | — | — | ✓ | · | — | Klaviyo, Postscript, Justuno, Alia | |
| IM8 | im8health.com | longevity | — | — | — | — | ✓ | · | — | Klaviyo, Attrac | |
| Jocko Fuel | jockofuel.com | sports | 1.0s | no field, buttons only | 15% off | ✓ | · | No thanks | Klaviyo, Attentive, Octane AI, Attrac, PushOwl | ||
| Kion | getkion.com | sports | — | — | — | — | · | · | — | Klaviyo, Attrac | |
| Lemme | lemmelive.com | mass | — | — | — | — | ✓ | · | — | Klaviyo, Attentive, Postscript | |
| Live Conscious | liveconscious.com | mass | 1.5s | no field, buttons only | up to 30% | ✓ | · | No thanks, I'll pay full price | Klaviyo, Attentive, PushOwl | ||
| LMNT | drinklmnt.com | mass | — | — | — | — | ✓ | · | — | — | |
| Magic Mind | magicmind.com | wellness | — | — | — | — | · | · | — | Klaviyo, Octane AI | |
| MUD\WTR | mudwtr.com | mass | — | — | — | — | ✓ | · | — | Klaviyo, Postscript | |
| Naked Nutrition | nakednutrition.com | value | — | no field, buttons only | — | 15% off | · | · | I’m not interested. | Attentive, OptiMonk, WisePops, Wunderkind, Emotive | |
| Needed | thisisneeded.com | clinical | — | — | — | — | ✓ | · | — | Klaviyo | |
| Neurohacker / Qualia | neurohacker.com | longevity | 3.5s | — | up to 75%, 75% off | ✓ | · | — | Klaviyo, Attentive | ||
| NOW Foods | nowfoods.com | value | — | — | — | — | ✓ | · | — | Klaviyo | |
| Nutrafol | nutrafol.com | clinical | — | — | — | $10 off | ✓ | · | — | Klaviyo, Attentive | |
| Obvi | myobvi.com | mass | 3.0s | no field, buttons only | same screen | 20% off | · | · | — | Klaviyo, Digioh | |
| OLLY | olly.com | mass | — | — | — | — | ✓ | · | — | Attentive | |
| OneSkin | oneskin.co | longevity | 10.5s | same screen | — | ✓ | · | NO THANKS | Attrac | ||
| Organifi | organifishop.com | mass | — | — | — | 15% off | ✓ | · | — | Klaviyo, Attentive, Octane AI | |
| Paleovalley | paleovalley.com | ancestral | — | — | — | — | ✓ | · | — | Klaviyo | |
| Perelel | perelelhealth.com | clinical | — | — | — | — | · | · | — | Klaviyo, Octane AI | |
| Physician's Choice | physicianschoice.com | mass | 2.5s | no field, buttons only | same screen | 40% off | · | · | — | Klaviyo, Privy, Alia, Octane AI | |
| Pique Life | piquelife.com | wellness | — | — | — | — | ✓ | · | — | Klaviyo, Attentive, Postscript, Alia, Digioh | |
| RAW Nutrition | getrawnutrition.com | sports | 2.0s | no field, buttons only | — | 25% off | · | · | No thanks, I'll pay full price | Klaviyo | |
| RenueByScience | renuebyscience.com | longevity | 5.5s | same screen | 15% off | ✓ | · | — | Klaviyo | ||
| RYSE Supps | rysesupps.com | sports | — | — | — | — | · | · | — | — | |
| RYZE Mushroom Coffee | ryzesuperfoods.com | wellness | — | — | — | — | ✓ | · | — | Klaviyo, Postscript, OptiMonk, WisePops, Wunderkind, Attrac, Emotive | |
| Seed | seed.com | clinical | — | — | — | — | ✓ | · | — | Digioh | |
| Sports Research | sportsresearch.com | value | — | — | — | — | ✓ | · | — | Attentive | |
| Transparent Labs | transparentlabs.com | sports | 1.5s | no field, buttons only | same screen | mystery discount | · | · | No thanks, I'll pay full price | Klaviyo, Postscript | |
| Tru Niagen | truniagen.com | longevity | 5.5s | no field, buttons only | — | 10% off | · | · | No Thanks | Klaviyo, Attrac | |
| Truvani | truvani.com | mass | 7.5s | email + phone | — | up to 73%, free starter kit | ✓ | ✓ | — | Klaviyo, Postscript, OptiMonk | |
| Vital Proteins | vitalproteins.com | mass | — | — | — | 15% off | ✓ | · | — | Klaviyo |
Measured by polling every 500ms from page load. 19 brands gave us a desktop timing. Median 3.0 seconds.
| Time to fire | Brands | Who |
|---|---|---|
| Under 2 seconds | 5 | Ancestral Supplements, ARMRA, Jocko Fuel, Live Conscious, Transparent Labs |
| 2 to 4 seconds | 6 | Alani Nu, Bloom Nutrition, Neurohacker / Qualia, Obvi, Physician's Choice, RAW Nutrition |
| 4 to 8 seconds | 4 | Goli, RenueByScience, Tru Niagen, Truvani |
| 8 to 15 seconds | 4 | BiOptimizers, Double Wood, Everyday Dose, OneSkin |
| Over 15 seconds | 0 | — |
The category norm is a pop-up inside the first few seconds, before the visitor has read anything. 3 of 54 pair it with a countdown on the pop-up itself, which is a scarcity device on an offer that is not actually scarce: Bloom Nutrition, Jocko Fuel, Live Conscious.
Pulled verbatim from the pop-up text, so this is what a first-time visitor actually sees, not what the brand's press page claims.
| Offer as written | Brands | Who |
|---|---|---|
| 15% off | 7 | Alani Nu, Goli, Jocko Fuel, Naked Nutrition, Organifi, RenueByScience, Vital Proteins |
| mystery discount | 3 | Ancestral Supplements, Bloom Nutrition, Transparent Labs |
| $10 off | 2 | Ancient Nutrition, Nutrafol |
| 25% off | 2 | Double Wood, RAW Nutrition |
| 30% off | 1 | ARMRA |
| 5% off | 1 | ARMRA |
| 70% off | 1 | Everyday Dose |
| free gift | 1 | Everyday Dose |
| up to 30% | 1 | Live Conscious |
| up to 75% | 1 | Neurohacker / Qualia |
| 75% off | 1 | Neurohacker / Qualia |
| 20% off | 1 | Obvi |
| 40% off | 1 | Physician's Choice |
| 10% off | 1 | Tru Niagen |
| up to 73% | 1 | Truvani |
| free starter kit | 1 | Truvani |
Rather than printing the number, these hide it behind a reveal, a scratch card or a “you've got” framing: Ancestral Supplements, Bloom Nutrition, Double Wood, Everyday Dose, Jocko Fuel, Naked Nutrition, Obvi, Physician's Choice, Transparent Labs, Tru Niagen, Truvani. The visitor has to act to find out what they won.
ARMRA, Bloom Nutrition, Double Wood, Four Sigmatic, RAW Nutrition, Truvani put a segmentation question on screen 1 and the email field on screen 2. Answers become profile properties, so the list arrives pre-segmented.
We clicked the primary control on every pop-up that fired and re-scanned, so a “step 2” here is one we actually reached.
| Brand | Step 1 on screen | Step 2 on screen | Step 1 asks | Step 2 asks |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ancestral Supplements | YOU'VE GOT A MYSTERY DISCOUNT REVEAL | YOU'VE GOT A MYSTERY DISCOUNT CONTINUE *first time customers only | no field, buttons only | |
| ARMRA | Start your revival with 30% Off Select your health goal to access your offer. GUT HEALTH IMMUNE HEALTH METABOL | Start your revival with 30% Off CONTINUE Offer applies to orders placed through ARMRA.com. Discount amount is | no field, buttons only | |
| Bloom Nutrition | You've got a mystery discount But first, let us know what you’re looking for! Fitness Fuel Gut Health Energy B | You've got a mystery discount Continue | no field, buttons only | |
| Jocko Fuel | YOU'VE GOT 15% OFF CLAIM 15% OFF No thanks | YOU'VE GOT 15% OFF CONTINUE | no field, buttons only | |
| Live Conscious | WOULD YOU LIKE UP TO 30% OFF? YES No thanks, I'll pay full price | 04 Minutes : 54 Seconds Remaining UNLOCK UP TO 30% OFF By submitting your email address, you agree to receive | no field, buttons only |
5 of 22 brands that showed a pop-up run a genuine two-screen flow where screen 1 does not ask for contact details. The rest put the field on the first screen.
This is the thin part of the category and therefore the opening. Below is every brand where we found a phone ask, a tap-to-text link or an SMS keyword.
| Brand | Where the phone ask sits | Mechanic | TCPA text present | Footer keyword |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bucked Up | footer form | · | — | |
| Ghost Lifestyle | footer form | ✓ | — | |
| Jocko Fuel | footer keyword only | keyword | · | Text Jockofuel to 24672 |
| Truvani | Desktop, step 1 | typed number field | · | — |
Footer email field: 33 of 54. Footer phone field: 3 of 54. So even the passive surface is email-first almost everywhere.
The cheapest copy test on the list. 10 of 54 write the refusal as a cost to the visitor rather than a neutral close.
| Brand | Decline copy, verbatim |
|---|---|
| Live Conscious | “No thanks, I'll pay full price” |
| RAW Nutrition | “No thanks, I'll pay full price” |
| Transparent Labs | “No thanks, I'll pay full price” |
| Naked Nutrition | “I’m not interested.” |
| Bloom Nutrition | “I'm not sure!” |
| Everyday Dose | “No, thanks” |
| Double Wood | “No thanks” |
| Jocko Fuel | “No thanks” |
| OneSkin | “NO THANKS” |
| Tru Niagen | “No Thanks” |
Loaded separately on an iPhone viewport with an iOS user agent. 19 of 54 fired a pop-up on mobile. 1 serve visibly different content there.
| Brand | Desktop says | Mobile says |
|---|---|---|
| Ancestral Supplements | YOU'VE GOT A MYSTERY DISCOUNT REVEAL | TRY YOUR LUCK Scratch below to see what you win YOU'VE GOT A MYSTERY DISCOUNT |
Fingerprinted from the scripts each storefront loads. Useful the next time somebody proposes buying a tool: this is who is actually running in our category.
| Vendor | Brands | Who |
|---|---|---|
| Klaviyo | 41 | 1st Phorm, AG1, Alani Nu, Ancestral Supplements, ARMRA, Arrae, Bare Performance Nutrition, Bloom Nutrition, Bucked Up, Bulletproof, Cymbiotika, Double Wood, Everyday Dose, Four Sigmatic, Ghost Lifestyle, Goli, Heart & Soil, IM8, Jocko Fuel, Kion, Lemme, Live Conscious, Magic Mind, MUD\WTR, Needed, Neurohacker / Qualia, NOW Foods, Nutrafol, Obvi, Organifi, Paleovalley, Perelel, Physician's Choice, Pique Life, RAW Nutrition, RenueByScience, RYZE Mushroom Coffee, Transparent Labs, Tru Niagen, Truvani, Vital Proteins |
| Recharge | 19 | 1st Phorm, Ancestral Supplements, Arrae, Bare Performance Nutrition, Bloom Nutrition, Cymbiotika, Goli, Jocko Fuel, Kion, Live Conscious, MUD\WTR, Needed, OLLY, Organifi, Physician's Choice, Pique Life, RYZE Mushroom Coffee, Truvani, Vital Proteins |
| Gorgias | 17 | 1st Phorm, Alani Nu, Ancestral Supplements, Ancient Nutrition, ARMRA, Arrae, Bare Performance Nutrition, Bucked Up, Everyday Dose, Four Sigmatic, Ghost Lifestyle, IM8, Jocko Fuel, Kion, Needed, Obvi, Truvani |
| Attentive | 14 | Ancient Nutrition, Bare Performance Nutrition, Bloom Nutrition, Cymbiotika, Jocko Fuel, Lemme, Live Conscious, Naked Nutrition, Neurohacker / Qualia, Nutrafol, OLLY, Organifi, Pique Life, Sports Research |
| Attrac | 10 | Ancestral Supplements, Bloom Nutrition, Four Sigmatic, Goli, IM8, Jocko Fuel, Kion, OneSkin, RYZE Mushroom Coffee, Tru Niagen |
| Octane AI | 8 | Ancient Nutrition, Bare Performance Nutrition, Four Sigmatic, Jocko Fuel, Magic Mind, Organifi, Perelel, Physician's Choice |
| Postscript | 8 | Ghost Lifestyle, Heart & Soil, Lemme, MUD\WTR, Pique Life, RYZE Mushroom Coffee, Transparent Labs, Truvani |
| Retention.com | 7 | 1st Phorm, Arrae, MUD\WTR, Naked Nutrition, Obvi, Pique Life, Transparent Labs |
| Alia | 6 | Double Wood, Everyday Dose, Ghost Lifestyle, Heart & Soil, Physician's Choice, Pique Life |
| Opensend | 5 | Ancestral Supplements, Everyday Dose, Perelel, RYSE Supps, Truvani |
| OptiMonk | 5 | ARMRA, Bare Performance Nutrition, Naked Nutrition, RYZE Mushroom Coffee, Truvani |
| Typeform | 5 | Arrae, Ghost Lifestyle, Heart & Soil, Magic Mind, Needed |
| Digioh | 4 | 1st Phorm, Obvi, Pique Life, Seed |
| WisePops | 4 | ARMRA, Bare Performance Nutrition, Naked Nutrition, RYZE Mushroom Coffee |
| Wunderkind | 4 | ARMRA, Bare Performance Nutrition, Naked Nutrition, RYZE Mushroom Coffee |
| Stay AI | 4 | ARMRA, Lemme, Obvi, RAW Nutrition |
| Emotive | 4 | ARMRA, Bare Performance Nutrition, Naked Nutrition, RYZE Mushroom Coffee |
| Back in Stock app | 3 | 1st Phorm, Pique Life, Sports Research |
| Justuno | 3 | Ancient Nutrition, Cymbiotika, Heart & Soil |
| Swym (BIS) | 2 | Bulletproof, RenueByScience |
| Privy | 2 | Cymbiotika, Physician's Choice |
| PushOwl | 2 | Jocko Fuel, Live Conscious |
22 brands showed nothing overlaid in 42 seconds of watching, on desktop or mobile. They are not absent from list building, they just do it passively. This is what they run instead, captured and screenshotted the same way.
| Brand | Site | Where it sits | Asks for | Copy on the unit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| AG1 | drinkag1.com | footer | SHOP The Pouch Travel Packs REVIEWS AG1 Reviews on Trustpilot Third-Party Testing Informed Sport Cologne List LEARN MORE AG1 Reviews Ingredients Benefits FAQs ABOUT About Us Refer Friends Partners Imp | |
| Ancient Nutrition | ancientnutrition.com | in-page block | Get $10 off your next order when you sign up for emails. Subscribe | |
| Bucked Up | buckedup.com | footer | email + phone | JOIN THE BUCKED UP FAM Become a VIP and score exclusive offers, training tips, and an exclusive discount on your first order—delivered right to your inbox. Full Name Email Address Mobile Phone Number |
| Bulletproof | bulletproof.com | footer | Stay Bulletproof: Subscribe Today Enter your Email to Subscribe I'M IN | |
| Function Health | functionhealth.com | footer | Company Join Function Login Newsroom Security Careers Contact us Explore What people say About MRI & CT Pricing Testing locations Community Gift Function For employers For practitioners For creators S | |
| Ghost Lifestyle | ghostlifestyle.com | footer | email + phone | Enter email address (required) SUBSCRIBE * E-mail Address Required Enter phone number SUBSCRIBE ** I agree to receive recurring automated marketing text messages (e.g. cart reminders) at the phone num |
| Heart & Soil | heartandsoil.co | in-page block | Get weekly health insights delivered to your inbox so you can radically improve your health Join 155,000+ Subscribers JOIN FREE | |
| IM8 | im8health.com | footer | SHOP Premium Core Nutrition The Beckham Stack Merchandise Shop All COMPANY About Us Inter Miami CF Science Impact LEARN Reviews Ingredients Quality and Standards IM8 Ambassador Program IM8 vs AG1 Next | |
| Lemme | lemmelive.com | footer | be first to get the goods Email SUBSCRIBE By entering your email and clicking the submit button you agree to receive marketing email messages from Lemme at the email address provided. Unsubscribe at a | |
| LMNT | drinklmnt.com | in-page block | On a mission to restore health through hydration. Sign up for Salty Science and the inside scoop on LMNT launches. Stay Salty | |
| MUD\WTR | mudwtr.com | footer | We Make a Newsletter We make a newsletter people actually look forward to. One thing to read, one thing to watch, one thing to listen to—curated for curious minds and better days. Email Join | |
| Needed | thisisneeded.com | footer | Join our community Subscribe to our newsletter for science-backed guidance and real support, delivered to your inbox each week. Email address By submitting my email, I consent to receive marketing ema | |
| NOW Foods | nowfoods.com | footer | Find a Store Retailer Login Switch to NOW Canada Stay in the Know with NOW Sign-up for our monthly newsletter to lead a healthier life. By submitting my email, I give my consent to transfer this infor | |
| Nutrafol | nutrafol.com | footer | Sign up to our mailing list and get $10 off your first subscription order. By signing up, you agree to our Sign-Up and Save Policy and our Privacy Policy. Already a customer? Log in to your myNutrafol | |
| OLLY | olly.com | footer | Sign up to get promos, giveaways and product news FAQs Learn About Subscriptions Contact Find a Store Careers Help Center Become an OLLY Ambassador | |
| Organifi | organifishop.com | footer | Take an extra 15% off your first order. We'll also send you delicious recipes, product updates, and more. SUBSCRIBE VIA SMS Account Our Story FAQs Manage Subscriptions Green Juice 101 Gift Card Store | |
| Paleovalley | paleovalley.com | in-page block | QUICK LINKS Home Store Articles Podcasts Recipes About Us Contact Us Partner With Us TOP PRODUCTS 100% Grass Fed Beef Sticks Pasture-Raised Pork Sticks 100% Grass Fed Bone Broth Protein 100% Grass Fed | |
| Pique Life | piquelife.com | in-page block | Claim 12 samples with any purchase. A $30 gift, on us! | |
| RYZE Mushroom Coffee | ryzesuperfoods.com | in-page block | HOW I RYZE Join The RYZE Club For exclusive offers, giveaways, and wellness tips Enter your email and select the subscribe button to sign up for our newsletter. Email ㅤSIGN UPㅤ | |
| Seed | seed.com | footer | [logo] Home Pioneering microbiome science [R+D] for human and planetary health since 2016. Science with Seed—nerdy reads for your inbox. By signing up you consent to receive Seed emails. *These statem | |
| Sports Research | sportsresearch.com | footer | Be the first to know about new products, exclusive offers, and much more. | |
| Vital Proteins | vitalproteins.com | in-page block | Unlock 15% off Today Plus, be the first to know about new products, offers, perks and more when you sign up below for email. SIGN ME UP NO, THANKS |
Ghost and Bucked Up are the only brands in the whole set whose embedded unit takes a phone number as well as an email, each with its own consent control. That is the pattern to copy for our footer, which currently asks for an email on every page and never asks for a number.
Every pop-up we caught, as we caught it. Brands where nothing fired are listed at the end so the absence is on the record too.


stack: Klaviyo, Gorgias




stack: Klaviyo, Attrac, Recharge, Opensend, Gorgias




stack: Klaviyo, OptiMonk, WisePops, Wunderkind, Stay AI, Emotive, Gorgias

stack: Klaviyo, Attentive, OptiMonk, WisePops, Wunderkind, Octane AI, Recharge, Emotive, Gorgias









stack: Klaviyo, Attentive, Attrac, Recharge


stack: Klaviyo, Alia




stack: Klaviyo, Alia, Opensend, Gorgias

stack: Klaviyo, Octane AI, Attrac, Gorgias




stack: Klaviyo, Attrac, Recharge




stack: Klaviyo, Attentive, Octane AI, Attrac, Recharge, PushOwl, Gorgias




stack: Klaviyo, Attentive, Recharge, PushOwl

stack: Attentive, OptiMonk, WisePops, Wunderkind, Retention.com, Emotive



stack: Klaviyo, Attentive




stack: Klaviyo, Digioh, Stay AI, Retention.com, Gorgias



stack: Attrac




stack: Klaviyo, Privy, Alia, Octane AI, Recharge


stack: Klaviyo, Stay AI




stack: Klaviyo, Swym (BIS)




stack: Klaviyo, Postscript, Retention.com


stack: Klaviyo, Attrac

stack: Klaviyo, Postscript, OptiMonk, Recharge, Opensend, Gorgias

stack: Klaviyo

stack: Attentive, Justuno, Octane AI, Gorgias

stack: Klaviyo, Gorgias

stack: Klaviyo, Swym (BIS)


stack: Klaviyo, Postscript, Alia, Typeform, Gorgias

stack: Klaviyo, Postscript, Justuno, Alia, Typeform

stack: Klaviyo, Attrac, Gorgias

stack: Klaviyo, Attentive, Postscript, Stay AI


stack: Klaviyo, Postscript, Recharge, Retention.com

stack: Klaviyo, Recharge, Typeform, Gorgias

stack: Klaviyo

stack: Klaviyo, Attentive

stack: Attentive, Recharge

stack: Klaviyo, Attentive, Octane AI, Recharge

stack: Klaviyo

stack: Klaviyo, Attentive, Postscript, Alia, Digioh, Recharge, Back in Stock app, Retention.com

stack: Klaviyo, Postscript, OptiMonk, WisePops, Wunderkind, Attrac, Recharge, Emotive

stack: Digioh

stack: Attentive, Back in Stock app

stack: Klaviyo, Recharge
1st Phorm (1stphorm.com); Arrae (arrae.com); Create Wellness (createwellness.com); Cymbiotika (cymbiotika.com); Garden of Life (gardenoflife.com); Gorilla Mind (gorillamind.com); Kion (getkion.com); Magic Mind (magicmind.com); Perelel (perelelhealth.com); RYSE Supps (rysesupps.com)
No pop-up and no embedded unit captured. Two of the three timed out on load repeatedly. Worth a manual pass on a real laptop before concluding anything about them.
Scratch cards, card flips, wheels and beat-the-dealer units are the loudest thing in DTC capture right now. 11 of the 54 brands in this document already run one. I pulled the four named examples apart to see what is really underneath, because the mechanic and the legal structure are two different questions and most brands blur them.
They look like one tactic. They are not. One is a real sweepstakes with a real prize, and it is the list-building engine. The other is an everyone-wins reveal with no prize at all, and it is offer presentation on the buying path. GRÜNS and Javvy both run both, and keep them apart.
| Machine 1 · real sweepstakes | Machine 2 · everyone-wins reveal | |
|---|---|---|
| Job | Build the list | Present the offer, lift cart conversion |
| Prize | A real item of stated value, one winner by random draw | Nothing is drawn. Every visitor collects every reward. |
| Contact fields | Email and phone | None. No email field on the page at all. |
| Legal apparatus | Official rules, no-purchase-necessary, odds statement, state exclusions, named sponsor, alternative entry method | None, and none is needed, because nothing is being raffled |
| Live examples | GRÜNS x Skylight calendar · GRÜNS monthly Apple Watch · Javvy x Comfrt hoodie | GRÜNS flip-to-win · Physician's Choice, Everyday Dose, Transparent Labs, Obvi scratch cards |
| Where the risk sits | Sweepstakes compliance, which is a solved problem with a checklist | Saying “win” when everybody wins, which is an advertising-claims question |
Both of these are live pages, quoted verbatim. Note that the state exclusion list is the dial: registration and bonding thresholds are what drive it, and the two brands set it differently.
| Clause | GRÜNS x Skylight | Javvy x Comfrt |
|---|---|---|
| No purchase | “NO PURCHASE OR PAYMENT OF ANY KIND IS NECESSARY TO ENTER OR WIN. A PURCHASE WILL NOT INCREASE YOUR CHANCES OF WINNING.” | “There is no purchase necessary to enter or win.” |
| Eligibility | 49 states plus DC, excluding Rhode Island, 18+ | 46 states plus DC, excluding Hawaii, Alaska, Michigan and Rhode Island |
| Prize value | Skylight calendar, supplied by Skylight, who are named as prize supplier only | “One (1) Javvy X Comfrt Hoodie (approximate retail value: $69.95)” |
| Odds | Stated in rules | “Odds of winning depend on the total number of eligible entries received.” |
| Alternative entry | Rules published separately per promotion | Mail-in entry offered alongside the form, which is what keeps it out of lottery territory |
| Sponsor | Named, with full street address in Austin, TX | Named: Javvy Coffee Company |
| Other | Partner disclaimed as non-administrator | Monthly, entries do not carry over; “Sponsor's computer is the official time-keeping device” |
If we ever attach a real prize to a capture unit, this is the checklist, and it is not optional. If we do not want that overhead, the answer is not to run a cheaper version of a sweepstakes; it is to run Machine 2 and never use the word win.
Headline is “PICK A CARD for FREE GIFTS and DISCOUNTS” over a grid of face-down cards. The counter underneath reads “You've collected 0/4 prizes!” and the button says “Flip 4 More Cards”. I flipped one: it revealed FREE SHIPPING, the counter moved to 1/4 and the button became “Flip 3 More Cards”. You are not gambling, you are being walked through an offer stack four beats at a time.


Two things confirm it is presentation rather than chance. There is no email or phone field anywhere on the page, so it is not a capture unit at all, and there are no rules or odds links, because nothing is being drawn. It sits on the path to Add to Cart.
And it is a programme, not a gimmick. GRÜNS runs flip-to-win in variants by audience, benefit, offer
type and collaboration: flip-to-win, flip-to-win-glp-1,
gut-health-gwp-flip-to-win, gut-health-gwp-flip-to-win-pdp,
flip-to-win-three-flavors-sub, flip-to-win-minions. I loaded the generic, the GLP-1 and
the gut-health versions: identical mechanics and the same first reveal in all three, so the game logic is
fixed and only the surrounding page changes.
GRÜNS' first-order landing pages are where contact details are actually collected. They carry
both an email and a phone field and they link to the monthly Apple Watch giveaway rules. They are also cut
by paid channel and by city: first-order-firecracker,
first-order-firecracker-applovin, first-order-firecracker-snapchat,
firecracker-chicago, firecracker-vip, plus surprise-* variants per flavour
and collaboration.


Worth noting against our own gap: only 3 of the 54 brands in this document ask for a phone number on site, and GRÜNS is doing it on the paid landing page rather than in a pop-up.
Same mechanic, delivered as an overlay instead of a page. All four of these were captured on 27 August.




Alia appears on 9 of the brands examined for this document: Physician's Choice, Everyday Dose, Double Wood, Heart & Soil, Pique Life, Ghost, Splitflask, GRÜNS and Javvy. Every one of them runs either the reveal pattern or a question-first pattern. This is what makes the trend look like a wave: it is a template that ships with the app, at $100 a month self-serve, not nine independent creative decisions.
Splitflask's stop-the-clock game, where you try to halt a timer at exactly two seconds, was not running when I loaded the site on 27 August. What served instead was a plain overlay: “ENJOY 10% OFF SPLITFLASK / Your email address / YES PLEASE / TRUSTED BY 30,000+ BEVERAGE GOBLINS WORLDWIDE!”. Either it is in rotation or it has been retired. A game that gives the offer away even when you lose has a short shelf life, because the second time a shopper sees it the outcome is already known.

Javvy's scratch-and-win landing page could not be located from outside. Their sitemap lists products only, and their theme answers 200 with homepage content for every path I probed, so the page is unindexed and reachable only from the email that carried it. Javvy does run Alia, Klaviyo and Attentive, and does run a real hoodie sweepstakes, so the pattern is consistent; I just could not screenshot the unit. The blackjack unit (beat the dealer, hit or stand) could not be verified either: both javvy.com and kickhealth.com answer 403 to us. Send either link and I will capture both properly.
Take the structure. The lift comes from two things that need no game at all: the contact ask moves to step 2 after a small commitment, and the discount number is hidden so nobody self-disqualifies before engaging. Six brands in this document get the same effect with a goal question instead, and a question hands back zero-party data where a scratch card hands back nothing.
Take the gift framing over the discount framing. GRÜNS reveals free shipping and free gifts; OneSkin offers a free set with a stated $58 value. Both protect margin and seed product trial in a way that a percentage does not.
Leave the word win. If everybody wins, calling it winning is an advertising-claims problem rather than a gambling one, and it is the one part of this trend with no upside for us.
Leave it off the homepage. Every serious version of this we found runs on a paid landing page, where the visitor arrived from an ad or an email and the aesthetic is contained. Nobody good is putting a casino on the brand's front door.
Fresh Chromium browser per brand, no history or cookies, US locale, America/New_York timezone. Desktop 1440×900 with a macOS Chrome user agent; mobile 390×844 with an iPhone user agent. From load we polled every 500ms for 27 seconds, scrolling at 4s and 10s, scanning the main document and every child frame including cross-origin iframes. On the first hit we screenshotted the pop-up element itself, then clicked the primary control and re-scanned for a second step, then triggered exit intent by dispatching mouseout above the viewport. Cookie and privacy banners were filtered out by pattern.
The capture ran from a Madrid IP address, with a US locale and an Eastern timezone set in the browser. Several brands responded with a country selector naming Spain, which proves geo-detection is IP-based and our locale settings did not override it. US-only pop-ups will not have fired for us.
So a blank row is not evidence that a brand runs no pop-up. Treat the 22 captured pop-ups as solid and the 32 blanks as unresolved. Section 11 lists them with links for a manual pass from a US connection.
The detector catches any overlay, so it also caught things that are not opt-in units. These were classified and removed rather than counted: cart drawers (Cymbiotika, BPN, Arrae, Perelel), country and language selectors (Naked Nutrition, Four Sigmatic, Magic Mind), and a product purchase block (Kion). Where a brand's real pop-up sat behind one of those, we kept the real one: Naked Nutrition's 15% offer and BPN's mobile signup were both promoted out from behind a drawer.
Three of those are worth stealing anyway even though they are not opt-in pop-ups. Cymbiotika runs a cart gift picker: “CONGRATS, Choose Your Free Gift. Thanks for spending $110.” Perelel asks “TELL US YOUR DUE DATE” inside the cart with a due-date calculator, which is zero-party data collected at the moment of highest intent. BPN shows a free-shipping progress bar in the drawer.
Counts are floors. 32 of 54 brands showed no overlay to an automated browser, so every “6 of 54” in this document means at least that many. A brand that gates its pop-up on engagement signals a script cannot produce will read here as running none.
Timings are one observation each, from one location on one day. A brand that fired at 2.0s here may be running a 3s rule with jitter, or A/B testing the delay.
No opt-in rates. Nothing here tells us how well any of these convert; that data is not public. This document is about mechanics and copy, which are the parts we can copy and test.
Nothing was submitted. No email address or phone number was entered on any competitor site, so post-submit behaviour, welcome sequences and SMS confirmation flows are out of scope.
Everything above watches these brands from the outside, through a browser. This section joins two TrendTrack datasets onto the same 54 brands, pulled 2 September 2026: the welcome emails their capture programmes actually send (US-collected, so it sees brands whose pop-ups refused a Madrid IP), and the Meta ad landing pages they keep paying to run.
The Madrid capture left 35 rows with no timed pop-up. TrendTrack's archive holds welcome emails for 25 of them — those capture programmes are live and feeding, we just never saw the front door. The ten still dark on both passes: 1st Phorm, Bare Performance Nutrition, Create Wellness, Garden of Life, Lemme, LMNT, Needed, NOW Foods, Nutrafol, Paleovalley. Treat absence from the archive as a coverage gap, not proof of absence: four of the ten (Paleovalley, Lemme, Nutrafol, LMNT) are heavy Meta spenders with active offer pages, so their capture almost certainly exists and simply is not seeded yet. These ten are the priority rows for the Section 11 manual re-check.
Of the 40 brands with a welcome on file, 13 lead with a percentage discount, 4 with a gift (Ancient Nutrition, Bulletproof, IM8, Pique Life), 8 with explicitly no promotion, and 13 carry no promotion label in the archive; cashback and free delivery appear once each. A meaningful minority welcomes without an offer — brand-led onboarding rather than a broken promise. This is the post-submit half of the offer table in section 03: what the pop-up promises, the welcome pays out. Several picked rows read “Confirm Your Subscription” — those brands run double opt-in, itself worth knowing.
Ranking brands by ads active on flagged offer/funnel pages right now: Goli runs 846 active ads into a bare discount link (goli.com/discount/daily25 — the URL applies the code and dumps into the store), Paleovalley 239 across BOGO offer pages, Lemme 152 across debloat funnels, Magic Mind 131 across offer LPs — one literally suffixed welcome-v1 — Nutrafol 54 including a laborday26 page, Gorilla Mind 48 across intro-offer LPs. Notably, zero gamified pages (flip/scratch/spin) appear in any of the 54 brands' tracked Meta ads — the reveal units of section 09 live on-site via Alia, while the ad money goes to plain offer funnels.
C1 shrinks from a 35-row re-crawl to a 10-row priority list (above). C3 is 80% answered without seeding an inbox: the welcome offer is now on file for 40 brands; tagged-address seeding is still the only way to see cadence and step count. C4 becomes a query, not a project — every archived email carries a promotion-type label, so offer-depth drift is a monthly filter. C5 is blocked upstream: TrendTrack's facet counts 1,149 Alia installs but its shop filter returns one row — raised as a data bug, revisit before building the cohort. And one 09 loose end closed: Javvy's unreachable funnels surface in their ad library at try.javvycoffee.com.
| Brand | Pop-up fired | Welcomes on file | Sent | Welcome offer | Welcome subject | Active ads | Top offer/funnel LP in ads |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Everyday Dose | 13.0s | 1 | 2026-04-21 | No Promotion | 💌 You’re invited to our exclusive club | 1290 | /discount/gerrybrooks · 1 active |
| Goli | 5.5s | 2 | 2025-11-26 | No Promotion | Confirm Your Subscription | 1274 | /discount/daily25 · 846 active |
| Arrae | — | 2 | 2026-02-25 | No Promotion | Confirm Your Subscription | 857 | /pages/try-tone-gummies · 15 active |
| Naked Nutrition | — | 1 | 2025-11-20 | · | Welcome to Naked Nutrition | 771 | — |
| Perelel | — | 5 | 2025-11-25 | · | Welcome to Perelel ✨ Here’s 25% off | 509 | — |
| Pique Life | — | 5 | 2025-12-18 | Gift With Purchase | New & Limited Edition: Pu’er Red | 503 | — |
| IM8 | — | 5 | 2026-05-25 | Gift With Purchase | Claim Your Free Welcome Kit! | 488 | /pages/newyearoffer · 1 active |
| Transparent Labs | 1.5s | 5 | 2026-03-11 | Discount % | Here's 10% off | 464 | /collections/all/products/gift-card · 3 active |
| Lemme | — | · | — | — | — | 434 | /pages/debloat-lp-v2 · 81 active |
| Ancestral Supplements | 1.0s | 5 | 2025-11-21 | · | Your Mystery Discount is Inside | 363 | — |
| Cymbiotika | — | 2 | 2025-11-18 | · | Welcome to Cymbiotika 🌱 | 361 | — |
| Function Health | — | 1 | 2026-07-27 | Cashback | 2 days only: $50 toward your first year of Function. | 328 | /gifthealth · 2 active |
| Paleovalley | — | · | — | — | — | 308 | /offers/grass-fed-bone-broth-protein-bogo-sd · 91 active |
| LMNT | — | · | — | — | — | 306 | /products/lmnt-recharge-wholesale-variety-pack · 2 active |
| Needed | — | · | — | — | — | 263 | — |
| Ghost Lifestyle | — | 2 | 2025-11-23 | Discount % | WELCOME TO THE GHOST® FAM | 226 | — |
| Nutrafol | — | · | — | — | — | 212 | /hair/women/lp/core/laborday26 · 14 active |
| Gorilla Mind | — | 2 | 2025-11-22 | · | Welcome - Your Timing Couldn’t Be Better | 197 | /pages/gorilla-mind-creatine-gummies-intro-off · 30 active |
| Magic Mind | — | 2 | 2025-11-02 | · | Confirm Your Subscription | 174 | /pages/mental-performance-shot-lp-lh-5rw-welco · 102 active |
| OneSkin | 10.5s | 5 | 2026-05-08 | Discount % | WELCOME TO ROUTE ONE | 148 | — |
| Jocko Fuel | 1.0s | 5 | 2026-02-25 | Discount % | Welcome to Jocko Fuel 💪 | 133 | — |
| Physician's Choice | 2.5s | 2 | 2025-10-31 | · | Welcome! Here's your 25% off discount | 130 | /pages/hyt-30-day-supply-offer-lp1 · 20 active |
| Seed | — | 5 | 2026-05-07 | Discount % | Welcome, Superorganism | 110 | — |
| RAW Nutrition | 2.0s | 4 | 2025-11-01 | · | Confirm Your Subscription | 99 | — |
| 1st Phorm | — | · | — | — | — | 62 | — |
| Obvi | 3.0s | 3 | 2026-04-19 | Discount % | You're in! Let's get you glowing with 20% Off. | 60 | /pages/menostrong-glp-1-lp · 42 active |
| Kion | — | 5 | 2026-04-04 | Discount % | Welcome to Kion! | 59 | — |
| RenueByScience | 5.5s | 1 | 2025-11-25 | No Promotion | Confirm Your Subscription | 58 | — |
| Ancient Nutrition | — | 5 | 2026-08-05 | Gift With Purchase | 🎁 Here’s your welcome gift! | 57 | — |
| Tru Niagen | 5.5s | 5 | 2026-04-19 | Discount % | ⭐ Welcome! Here's $15 off your first order. ⭐ | 57 | /pages/welcome-offer · 2 active |
| NOW Foods | — | · | — | — | — | 44 | — |
| Heart & Soil | — | 1 | 2025-12-22 | · | Thanks for subscribing to the Radical Health Newslet… | 39 | — |
| BiOptimizers | 10.5s | · | — | — | — | 31 | — |
| MUD\WTR | — | 5 | 2025-11-23 | Discount % | Welcome to the MUD\WTR fam | 25 | /pages/rise-2-offer · 10 active |
| Double Wood | 9.0s | 1 | 2026-04-01 | Discount % | Welcome to Double Wood. | 22 | — |
| Organifi | — | 3 | 2025-11-04 | Discount % | Welcome to Organifi, Michael | 17 | — |
| Sports Research | — | 1 | 2026-01-02 | Free Delivery | Start Your Journey with Sports Research + Enjoy Free… | 17 | — |
| RYZE Mushroom Coffee | — | 5 | 2025-11-21 | · | Your Welcome Offer is Inside! 🍄 | 14 | — |
| RYSE Supps | — | 1 | 2026-03-06 | No Promotion | Welcome To The RYSE Team, friend! | 4 | — |
| Vital Proteins | — | 2 | 2025-10-15 | · | Welcome to Vital Proteins | 1 | — |
| ARMRA | 1.0s | 5 | 2026-08-24 | Discount % | ARMRA GLOSSARY: Autophagy | · | — |
| Bloom Nutrition | 2.0s | 5 | 2025-11-21 | · | 🌱 Welcome to Bloom 🌱 | · | — |
| Four Sigmatic | — | 5 | 2026-06-17 | Discount % | Welcome to the shroom movement 🍄 Here’s 15% Off | · | — |
| OLLY | — | 5 | 2026-06-27 | No Promotion | Welcome the summer breeze | · | — |
| AG1 | — | 4 | 2025-11-22 | No Promotion | Great to have you here! 💚 | · | — |
| Bucked Up | — | 4 | 2025-11-18 | · | Confirm Your Subscription | · | — |
| Bulletproof | — | 2 | 2025-12-06 | Gift With Purchase | The Coffee Kit You Need ☕ | · | — |
| Live Conscious | 1.5s | 2 | 2026-06-12 | No Promotion | 🍹Just Dropped! | · | — |
| Alani Nu | 2.5s | · | — | — | — | · | — |
| Bare Performance Nutrition | — | · | — | — | — | · | — |
| Create Wellness | — | · | — | — | — | · | — |
| Garden of Life | — | · | — | — | — | · | — |
| Neurohacker / Qualia | 3.5s | · | — | — | — | · | — |
| Truvani | 7.5s | · | — | — | — | · | — |
⚠ Read the numbers as floors, not censuses. The email archive holds one to five welcomes per brand, collected from TrendTrack's own US seed inboxes on their schedule, not ours — and its “Welcome” label is loose: a few records are mis-filed campaigns, and one goli.com record is another sender entirely. Where a brand's records disagree, the table shows the most welcome-like subject (explicit welcome first, then a double-opt-in confirm, then newest); offer counts above use the same rule. Landing-page counts cover Meta-tracked ads only, and an ad that stays active is revealed preference — TrendTrack publishes no open, click or conversion data, so persistence is the strongest signal available, not proof. Pull date 2 September 2026; refresh monthly alongside the C2 re-crawl.
Every brand that showed no overlay to our Madrid-based browser, with its link. Open each from a US connection, wait 30 seconds on the homepage, then trigger exit intent, and screenshot whatever appears. These are the rows most likely to change.
| # | Brand | Link | Category | What we did capture | Known stack |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | AG1 | drinkag1.com | mass | embedded footer form, screenshotted | Klaviyo |
| 2 | Ancient Nutrition | ancientnutrition.com | ancestral | embedded in-page form, screenshotted | Attentive, Justuno, Octane AI, Gorgias |
| 3 | Bucked Up | buckedup.com | sports | embedded footer form, screenshotted | Klaviyo, Gorgias |
| 4 | Bulletproof | bulletproof.com | mass | embedded footer form, screenshotted | Klaviyo, Swym (BIS) |
| 5 | Function Health | functionhealth.com | testing | embedded footer form, screenshotted | — |
| 6 | Ghost Lifestyle | ghostlifestyle.com | sports | embedded footer form, screenshotted | Klaviyo, Postscript, Alia, Typeform, Gorgias |
| 7 | Heart & Soil | heartandsoil.co | ancestral | embedded in-page form, screenshotted | Klaviyo, Postscript, Justuno, Alia, Typeform |
| 8 | IM8 | im8health.com | longevity | embedded footer form, screenshotted | Klaviyo, Attrac, Gorgias |
| 9 | Lemme | lemmelive.com | mass | embedded footer form, screenshotted | Klaviyo, Attentive, Postscript, Stay AI |
| 10 | LMNT | drinklmnt.com | mass | embedded in-page form, screenshotted | — |
| 11 | MUD\WTR | mudwtr.com | mass | embedded footer form, screenshotted | Klaviyo, Postscript, Recharge, Retention.com |
| 12 | Needed | thisisneeded.com | clinical | embedded footer form, screenshotted | Klaviyo, Recharge, Typeform, Gorgias |
| 13 | NOW Foods | nowfoods.com | value | embedded footer form, screenshotted | Klaviyo |
| 14 | Nutrafol | nutrafol.com | clinical | embedded footer form, screenshotted | Klaviyo, Attentive |
| 15 | OLLY | olly.com | mass | embedded footer form, screenshotted | Attentive, Recharge |
| 16 | Organifi | organifishop.com | mass | embedded footer form, screenshotted | Klaviyo, Attentive, Octane AI, Recharge |
| 17 | Paleovalley | paleovalley.com | ancestral | embedded in-page form, screenshotted | Klaviyo |
| 18 | Pique Life | piquelife.com | wellness | embedded in-page form, screenshotted | Klaviyo, Attentive, Postscript, Alia, Digioh |
| 19 | RYZE Mushroom Coffee | ryzesuperfoods.com | wellness | embedded in-page form, screenshotted | Klaviyo, Postscript, OptiMonk, WisePops, Wunderkind |
| 20 | Seed | seed.com | clinical | embedded footer form, screenshotted | Digioh |
| 21 | Sports Research | sportsresearch.com | value | embedded footer form, screenshotted | Attentive, Back in Stock app |
| 22 | Vital Proteins | vitalproteins.com | mass | embedded in-page form, screenshotted | Klaviyo, Recharge |
| 23 | 1st Phorm | 1stphorm.com | sports | nothing | Klaviyo, Digioh, Recharge, Back in Stock app, Retention.com |
| 24 | Arrae | arrae.com | wellness | nothing | Klaviyo, Recharge, Retention.com, Typeform, Gorgias |
| 25 | Create Wellness | createwellness.com | sports | nothing | — |
| 26 | Cymbiotika | cymbiotika.com | longevity | nothing | Klaviyo, Attentive, Justuno, Privy, Recharge |
| 27 | Garden of Life | gardenoflife.com | mass | nothing | — |
| 28 | Gorilla Mind | gorillamind.com | sports | nothing | — |
| 29 | Kion | getkion.com | sports | nothing | Klaviyo, Attrac, Recharge, Gorgias |
| 30 | Magic Mind | magicmind.com | wellness | nothing | Klaviyo, Octane AI, Typeform |
| 31 | Perelel | perelelhealth.com | clinical | nothing | Klaviyo, Octane AI, Opensend |
| 32 | RYSE Supps | rysesupps.com | sports | nothing | Opensend |
A US VPN exit node on this machine would let the same script run unattended and fill every row automatically, screenshots included. Failing that, the pattern to record per brand is: seconds to fire, offer as written, what step 1 asks for, whether a step 2 exists, the decline button copy, and whether a phone number is ever requested. Those six fields are what the tables above are built from.
What to do with all of the above: which variants to put into test, in what order, and how to keep pulling competitor data so we learn what actually works rather than what is merely common.
Every challenger below is lifted from a named brand in this document. “Control” is what our own pop-up did when checked on 27 August 2026: step 1 prints “DO YOU WANT 25% BACK ON YOUR FIRST ORDER” with an email field and a YES button, and the only way to refuse is the close cross.
| # | Test | Borrowed from | Control | Challenger | Primary metric | Reads in |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A1 | Hide the number | 11 of 54 · Everyday Dose, Physician's Choice, Transparent Labs, Obvi | “DO YOU WANT 25% BACK”, number stated up front | “You've got a discount” behind a reveal or scratch | Submit rate | ~3 days |
| A2 | Question before the email field | Double Wood's taxonomy is closest to our catalogue | Email field on screen 1 | “What are you working on?” → Energy · Sleep · Heart · Longevity · Metabolic, then email on screen 2 | Submit rate, plus how many answers we bank | ~1 week |
| A3 | Make the refusal cost something | Transparent Labs, Live Conscious, Qualia | Bare close cross | “No thanks, I'll pay full price” | Submit rate | ~3 days |
| A4 | Free gift with a stated value | OneSkin “FREE Skin Longevity Mini Set ($58 Value)” | 25% back on first order | A named free gift with its dollar value printed | Profit per visitor, not submit rate | 3–4 weeks |
| A5 | Free shipping instead of a discount | Sports Research — the only brand of 54 doing it | 25% back | Free shipping on the first order | Profit per visitor | 3–4 weeks |
| A6 | Countdown on the second screen | Live Conscious runs a 5-minute timer on step 2 | No timer | Timer on the screen that asks for the contact detail | Step-2 completion | ~1 week |
| A8 | Gift-reveal, on a paid landing page only | GRÜNS flip-to-win · OneSkin's “$58 Value” free set · see section 09b | 25% back stated on the homepage pop-up | A reveal that uncovers free gifts and free shipping, not a percentage, on an ad or email landing page rather than the brand homepage | Profit per visitor and first-order trial rate | 3–4 weeks |
| A7 | Fire time | Median across the set is 2.5s | Our current delay | 2s against 8s | Submit rate, and bounce must not move | ~1 week |
| # | Item | Borrowed from | What it changes |
|---|---|---|---|
| B1 | Phone field in the footer with its own consent control | Ghost and Bucked Up — the only 2 of 54 doing this | Our footer takes an email on every page and never asks for a number. This is the single least contested opening in the whole set: only 3 of 54 brands ask for a phone number anywhere. |
| B2 | Put the question on the exit pop-up | Four Sigmatic asks “What's your current wellness priority?” on exit intent | ⚠ Our exit pop-up did not fire at all when checked on 27 August. Confirm in Attrac whether it is off, frequency-capped or broken before designing anything for it. |
| B3 | Zero-party ask at cart stage | Perelel asks “TELL US YOUR DUE DATE” inside the cart with a calculator | Highest-intent moment on the site and we ask nothing there. Our analogue is a reorder interval or a goal. |
A single snapshot tells us what is common. Only repeat observation tells us what is working, because a brand that keeps a pattern for months has data behind it and one that drops it in weeks does not.
| # | Item | Why it earns its time | Effort |
|---|---|---|---|
| C1 | Re-run this capture from a US IP | Closes the 32 unresolved brands in section 11. Everything is already scripted, so a US VPN exit node on this machine turns the worklist into filled rows automatically, screenshots included. | 1 hour once a VPN exists |
| C2 | Schedule it monthly and diff against this baseline | The persistence signal. Offer depth, timing, step structure and decline copy per brand, month over month. A pattern that survives three months is validated by somebody else's testing budget. | Half a day to wire the cron and the diff |
| C3 | Subscribe to the competitor lists with tagged addresses | We deliberately submitted nothing this round, so everything after the click is unknown: welcome timing, how the discount is delivered, whether SMS confirmation is single or double opt-in, how hard they push subscription on message one. That is the half of the funnel we cannot see from the outside. | 2 hours to set up, then passive |
| C4 | Track offer depth per brand over time | Everyday Dose at 70% off plus 8 free gifts is either a high-margin bundle or a brand in trouble. One observation cannot tell them apart; three months of observations can, and it tells us where the floor on discounting in this category actually is. | Falls out of C2 for free |
| C5 | Track the Alia cohort specifically | Nine of the brands in this document run Alia and all nine run a reveal or question-first unit (section 09b). They are the leading indicator: if the reveal is still there in three months it is validated, and if they rotate off it we just watched the novelty expire without paying for the lesson. | Falls out of C2 for free |